Blog | Scandal, Sexuality, and Power: The Tragic Story of Lord Darnley

Who Was Lord Darnley?

Born in 1545 at Temple Newsam, Henry Stuart, better known as Lord Darnley, had a lot expected of him. As the son of Margaret Douglas, niece of King Henry VIII, and Matthew Stuart, Earl of Lennox, Darnley was a blend of Tudor and Stuart royalty. His family envisioned a bright future, solidified in 1564 when he married Mary, Queen of Scots, and became King Consort.

A Disastrous Reign as King Consort

Darnley’s reign as King Consort of Scotland was fraught with turmoil. Despite the grandeur of his title, his tenure was marked by incompetence, betrayal, and scandal. His ambition to wield power without fulfilling the responsibilities of kingship alienated him from Mary and the Scottish nobility.

Darnley’s Sexuality: A Controversial Mystery

Historians have long debated Darnley’s sexuality, a topic rarely discussed in the 16th century. Contemporary accounts describe Darnley as indulging in "unmanly pleasures," and his close relationship with David Rizzio, an Italian musician in Mary’s court, raised eyebrows. Witnesses claimed the two men were inseparable, with some stating they “lay in one bed together.”

Infidelity and Decline

While whispers of his relationships with men circulated, Darnley’s public infidelity with women was undeniable. He openly pursued affairs, fathered a child outside his marriage, and spent more time in Edinburgh’s brothels than in court. His behaviour pushed Mary to deny him the crown matrimonial, a move that fuelled his resentment.

The Mysterious Death of Lord Darnley

Darnley’s life ended under suspicious circumstances. On February 10, 1567, an explosion destroyed his lodging at Kirk o’ Field. His body was later discovered in a nearby orchard, surrounded by strange items like a dagger, a chair, and a rope. Despite centuries of speculation, the details of his murder remain unsolved.

Drawing of Kirk o’Field after the murder of Henry Stuart, Lord Darnley, 1567 © The National Archives

Legacy of Lord Darnley

Lord Darnley’s story is one of ambition, scandal, and tragedy. His likely bisexuality and indulgent lifestyle isolated him from allies and contributed to his downfall. While not a champion of LGBTQ+ causes, this aspect of his character offers a deeper understanding of his life.

Today, Darnley’s lineage connects to the modern royal family, a reminder of his lasting, if controversial, legacy.

Visit Temple Newsam to Learn More

Dive deeper into the life of Lord Darnley by visiting his childhood home at Temple Newsam, where history comes alive.